Provident Metals Scandal: What’s with the Fake Gold Rumors?

Written By Colin Kuehn  |  Gold 

We are a reader-supported website. That means we may earn a commission if you click links on our site and make a purchase. This is not financial advice. We recommend consulting with a professional for guidance about your specific situation.

In the exciting world of precious metals investing, the reputation and integrity of the dealer you choose to work with are crucial. Whether you are a seasoned investor or just beginning your journey in gold and silver investment, it is vital to partner with a reputable dealer to secure your wealth. Provident Metals, a well-known name in the industry, has recently been the subject of scrutiny and concern due to a "scandal" that has been circulating online. This article will explore the matter thoroughly and provide you with the necessary insights to make an informed decision about your investment.

What is Provident Metals?

a screenshot of Provident Metals homepage

Provident Metals is a leading dealer in precious metals, including gold, silver, platinum, palladium, and more. Based in Texas, they offer an extensive selection of bullion, coins, and rounds for investors. Furthermore, they specialize in offering precious metals for Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs), thereby facilitating a long-term, stable investment strategy.

What is the Provident Metals Scandal?

Recently, some allegations surfaced online, accusing Provident Metals of selling fake precious metals. According to these allegations, Provident Metals has been involved in selling fake gold and silver to unsuspecting investors. Given the severity of these claims, they have caused a stir in the investment community, prompting some to question the authenticity of their transactions with Provident Metals.

With that said, none of the allegations have been proven to be legitimate, and Provident Metals maintains a solid reputation with organizations like the BBB and TrustPilot.

It's also crucial to note that allegations of this nature are not uncommon in the precious metals industry. Accusations can often originate from unsatisfied customers or competitors aiming to tarnish a company's reputation. Therefore, it is vital to delve into the details and verify the facts before drawing any conclusions.

Does Provident Metals Sell Fake Gold or Silver?

a pile of free silver

While the allegations have drawn attention, it's important to remember that these online alligations remain unproven. 

Provident Metals is known to assay the precious metals they sell for authenticity, and it's also a member of the Industry Council for Tangible Assets (ICTA), Professional Numismatists Guild (PNG), and the American Numismatic Association (ANA). These memberships require stringent ethical conduct and transparent practices.

How to Ensure You're Buying Real Gold and Silver

To safeguard your investment, there are a few practices you can follow to verify the authenticity of gold and silver, even if purchased from reputable dealers.

  1. Certification: All reputable precious metal dealers will provide a certificate of authenticity with your purchase. This certificate is a guarantee of the purity and weight of the metal you have purchased.
  2. Assaying: This involves testing a metal to determine its purity and is one of the most accurate ways to verify the authenticity of gold and silver.
  3. Physical Checks: Physical properties of precious metals can be checked using simple tools. Gold and silver have specific weights, sizes, and even sounds when struck that can be used to identify their authenticity.
  4. Reputable Dealers: Always choose to deal with reputable and well-established sellers who have a proven track record in the industry.

Provident Metals Rating and Customer Reviews

a screenshot of provident metals BBB rating

BBB Rating

The Better Business Bureau (BBB) has assigned Provident Metals an A+ rating, which is the highest possible score. This rating is based on multiple factors, including the company's response to customer complaints, the transparency of business practices, and the length of time the company has been operating.

TrustPilot Score

On TrustPilot, Provident Metals has received a 3.3 out of 5 rating, reflecting a generally positive experience for most customers. Reviews highlight the company's prompt customer service, wide product selection, and competitive pricing.

What Customers are Saying

The majority of customer reviews for Provident Metals are positive, praising their professionalism, product quality, and delivery times. However, some customers have expressed dissatisfaction, often related to shipping times and customer service responsiveness. In most instances, Provident Metals has responded to these criticisms, demonstrating a commitment to addressing customer concerns.

Here are a few reviews posted to TrustPilot that are worth sharing here:

I just received my first shipment of silver krugerrands this morning, everything came packaged perfectly, the coins are perfect and shipping was as promised. I love the coins and will definitely order again.


#1 Top Choice for Bullion, online or anywhere else! Of the half dozen or so bullion dealers I have tried, Provident Metals is my favorite. I have placed 23 orders with Provident, while my second most favorite dealer only got my business 9 times.. and for good reason. Great Prices & Customer Service, Accurate Product Description Pages.. I've even had the pleasure of speaking with CEO Joe Merrick (real nice guy - very receptive and responsive). I will stick with Provident until they sell out! 😉 And hopefully they never do.

Provident Metals is simply one of the best companies I've ever dealt with. My newest order was a 1 KG Silver bar and they shipped free and fast. I got a tracking number same day too. It arrived discreetly and well packed. They are very professional.

So, Is Provident Metals Legit?

After a thorough review of the facts and considering the company's standing in various ratings and customer review platforms, it is clear that Provident Metals remains a reputable dealer in the precious metals market.

While allegations of selling fake precious metals can be serious, there doesn't seem to be any truth to these rumors and they remain unproven. The company has maintained a solid rating with consumer protection agencies, and has thousands of positive customer reviews online.

As always, it is crucial for investors to conduct their research and due diligence before making any investment decision. And while the allegations against Provident Metals certainly warrant attention, they do not decisively undermine the company's reputation and legitimacy. Consequently, investors should continue to exercise standard precautions, such as checking for certification and performing physical checks on their purchases, to ensure they are getting authentic precious metals.

a pile of free silver

Last Updated: June 19, 2023